
As ever
Kokonut Pundit continues to raise interesting questions about deaf and language perceptions. One reads lots of "it is about ALL deaf together regardless of mode", it's a thrust of my blog, I like to think I put certain realities forward to show we have a long way to go yet. We then tend to see the immediate polarising of views that show many deaf/HI sectors are travelling quite quickly in the opposite direction to every one else. You cannot have a deaf community unless people work together.
Language has overridden 'communication' as a priority in acceptance terms, on;ly the deaf could discuss the case that language and communications tend to be diametrically opposite things. This is because 'Language' defines them differently, and as a culture, whilst multi-communicational approaches define jack of all trades, not really one thing or another. All deaf accepting and being together, yes, the impossible dream of most of us, without us believing it is possible then awareness and equality is going to be hypothetical, most issues abound from the fact, we celebrate difference, more than we celebrate diversity.
Are deaf aware of that reality ? We churn (Sorry PROMOTE!), this message year on year, and day by relentless day, we strive via various routes, to spread the word, quite often in an evangelical fervour in the earnest hope it may become a reality, we HAVE to believe it is not impossible. For those not born with silver spoon of born deafness, yes this credo and earnest desire to level us all off on the same playing field can be driven by a fear, and the uncertainty of our own status, if we cannot bring the mountain to Mohamed, we will just assume mountains are merely obstacles to be climbed over, built on, or simply flattened.... As homo sapient it is in our genes to change environments to suit us, and not allow environments to dictate. Not always for our betterment.
There may be diversity of communication but little acceptances for some, if you are blind, no amount of pictured art, is going to heighten your appreciation of colour and light..... Diversity like multiculturalism, (Another impossible dream), are just words and aspirations. There is no coca-cola happy ending, I've always found that American dream a real paradox. I think acceptance of communications of us all takes priority over language, since language is what divides deaf. There are also still many racial, gender, and ethnic deaf divides that go on regardless if they all sign or not, they have their own deaf organisation, own beliefs, own schools, and congregate together, so whilst communication is common the will to bridge other divides isn't.
Should we all accept these divides as a right ? Multiculturalism is as much a Myth in America as here in Europe. It is the American dream after all, but look how it makes it so much harder to gain real equality, whilst we strive for that with mainstream we are on a fast track to the opposite amongst each other. Equality laws in reality validate non-inclusion in many areas. My other blog about Wales, distinctly states it is of welsh interest only, it doesn't really include deaf welsh interests as such outside that area, am I contributing to divides ? sectionalising welsh deaf from English/Scottish or Irish deaf ? I just trying to focus on an area I am familiar with, but other deaf logging in will find.. there is less interest and inclusion of them,just like Americans would.
You see images of 'all' deaf people signing e.g. black, Asian, Japanese, whatever, what you do NOT see are these people in the same rooms or clubs much. Now and then we see a multi-racial deaf thing and think yes we are succeeding where hearing aren't, what we do not see is after the photo shoot they go each their own ways... go online to see the plethora of these stand-alone deaf areas. Deaf TV even.... of course in that respect access means colonising culture... we all want level playing fields, but we all want the teams looking the same too.
I think deaf ignore many realities and try to promote an unity via communication and language that doesn't really exist in many areas. It seems the more we preach the less we really believe... All deaf sign, all hearing speak, and the damned in the middle, how do we include them ?
Dic Jones an welsh poet and Archdruid wrote "Being able to cry is what makes us human.." maybe its the only thing that unites...